Arena Season 2 is Live (Live Results on X and Bluesky)

LotR Race Analysis: Nameless Thing

In the realm of Middle-earth, amidst the well-documented races of Elves, Men, Dwarves, and Hobbits, there lurks a lesser-known, almost forgotten race: the Nameless Things. These enigmatic creatures reside in the deepest, unexplored parts of the world, far beneath the known paths of even the most daring Dwarven delvers.

Nameless things from Middle Earth
Nameless things from the Lord of the Rings Universe

Origins and Ancient Existence

The Nameless Things are said to be as old, if not older, than some of the oldest beings in the lore of Middle-earth, including Sauron himself. This suggests they predate the arrival of the Maiar to Arda, placing them among the most ancient inhabitants of the world. Gandalf mentions them only in passing, suggesting a depth to Middle-earth that even the wise do not fully understand. Their origins are shrouded in mystery, making them a subject of fascination and fear.

Habitats of the Nameless Things

According to Gandalf, these creatures dwell in the depths far below the deepest delvings of the Dwarves, in places where light has never reached. The specific locations of these beings are not detailed in the maps of Middle-earth, as their realms lie deep within the bowels of the earth, in the vast network of caves and tunnels that span the roots of the Misty Mountains and beyond. It is in these dark recesses that they have existed since time immemorial, untouched by the wars and the passing of ages on the surface.

Nature and Characteristics

The Nameless Things are described as being "slimier than fish," suggesting a form and texture that is unnatural to the inhabitants of the surface world. Their ability to navigate through the complex network of tunnels beneath the mountains implies a level of intelligence and adaptability. They are creatures of the dark, possibly blind or indifferent to the realm of light above, evolved to thrive in the eternal night of their subterranean world.

Interaction with Other Beings

Very little is known about the interactions of the Nameless Things with other races of Middle-earth. Their contact with the outside world seems minimal, save for the indirect encounter Gandalf describes during his pursuit of Durin's Bane, the Balrog of Moria. This rare event highlights the isolation and the secretive nature of these beings, living as they do at the fringes of the known world, where even the great powers tread cautiously.

The Role in the Larger Mythos

The inclusion of the Nameless Things in Tolkien’s universe adds a layer of depth and mystery, emphasizing that Middle-earth is a place of endless secrets and ancient histories yet to be uncovered. While they play no direct role in the events of the War of the Ring, their very existence expands the mythological canvas of Tolkien's work, suggesting a world rich with untold stories and unseen dangers.

The Nameless Things embody the unknown and the unexplored aspects of Middle-earth. They are a testament to Tolkien's ability to create a world with dimensions that extend beyond the immediate focus of his narratives, inviting readers and scholars to speculate about the vast, uncharted territories that lie deep beneath the familiar landscapes of Middle-earth. As such, they remain one of the most intriguing and least understood of Tolkien's creations, a mystery preserved in the dark, awaiting perhaps, the light of a future tale.

The Elder Scrolls: The Daedra and Dwemer Automatons

In the universe of The Elder Scrolls, the entities that most closely resemble the enigmatic nature of Tolkien's Nameless Things are the Daedra and the Dwemer Automatons. The Daedra, similar to the Nameless Things, inhabit realms that are largely inaccessible to the inhabitants of Tamriel. They exist beyond the normal realms of the world, in Oblivion, which plays a similar role to the dark, unreachable depths of Middle-earth. Like the Nameless Things, Daedra are ancient and possess their own complex societies and hierarchies that are largely unknown to the surface dwellers.

The Dwemer Automatons represent another parallel, being creations left behind by the long-vanished Dwemer race. These mechanical beings, found deep within the ruins that pepper the landscapes of Skyrim and Morrowind, suggest a hidden layer of history and technology that is scarcely understood by contemporary inhabitants, akin to the ancient and hidden nature of the Nameless Things.

Dungeons & Dragons: The Underdark Creatures

In Dungeons & Dragons, the Underdark is a vast subterranean network of interconnected caverns and cities, inhabited by a host of mysterious and often malevolent beings. Entities such as the illithids (mind flayers) and beholders share characteristics with the Nameless Things, including their preference for darkness and their ancient origins. The illithids, with their alien minds and inscrutable motives, particularly evoke the mysterious and unknowable aspect of the Nameless Things, thriving in the depths away from the light of the surface world.

Diablo: The Creatures of the Burning Hells

The Diablo franchise features the Burning Hells, home to demonic entities that are both ancient and malevolent. While these demons are well-documented in the lore of the Diablo universe, their chaotic and evil nature makes them comparable to Tolkien's creatures in their opposition to the known world's order. The Prime Evils—Diablo, Mephisto, and Baal—exhibit the timeless, malevolent persistence that Gandalf attributes to the Nameless Things, having existed long before the human world's current struggles and being deeply intertwined with the world's fabric.

Malazan Book of the Fallen: The Azath Houses

In Steven Erikson's Malazan Book of the Fallen, the Azath Houses, although not creatures, represent a similar concept to the Nameless Things. These living houses, which appear throughout the Malazan world, serve as prisons for ancient and powerful beings. The mysterious and largely unexplained nature of the Azath Houses, along with their role in containing entities that are older than the gods themselves, mirrors the enigmatic and ancient existence of the Nameless Things in Tolkien’s works.

Unique Characteristics and Comparative Mythology

Ancient Origins

One of the defining traits of the Nameless Things is their ancient origin, suggesting a presence in Middle-earth that predates even the oldest known powers like Sauron. This trait is shared with many creatures across different fantasy settings, where ancient beings often lurk in the world's depths, holding secrets lost to the upper worlds. These beings often embody the primal fears of the unknown that persist in the mythology of many cultures.

Inhabitants of the Depths

The preference for dwelling in the deepest parts of the world is a common theme across fantasy literature. It reflects the human fear of the depths and the unknown that resides within them. In each universe, these beings often guard or encapsulate ancient evils or lost knowledge, which is a central theme in the lore surrounding Tolkien's Nameless Things.

Interaction with the World

The Nameless Things, despite their power, do not interact directly with the surface world or its major events. This trait is seen in other fantasy creatures, where ancient beings exist on the periphery of the main stories, influencing events in subtle or indirect ways. Their influence is often felt rather than seen, adding a layer of depth and mystery to the world-building in their respective universes.

The Nameless Things of Tolkien's Middle-earth serve as a profound example of how ancient, enigmatic beings can add depth and intrigue to a fantasy universe. By comparing these entities to similar creatures in other fantasy worlds, it becomes apparent that the allure of the unknown and the ancient is a powerful narrative tool that resonates across different cultures and stories. These beings challenge the characters and the readers to ponder what might lie beyond the mapped territories, enhancing the mythic quality of their worlds.

The below table displays all characters from this race that have been included in The Arena. Pride and Prophecy has more detailed information on other races across fantasy universes.