Arena Season 2 is Live (Live Results on X and Bluesky)

Malazan Character Analysis: Fear Sengar

Race: Tiste Edur

Sex: Male

Faction: Hiroth

Overall Rating: 5.7

Alignment: Lawful Neutral

Arena Status: Active (S1)

Fear Sengar stands as a character of profound complexity, embodying the tumultuous spirit of the Tiste Edur. As the eldest son of House Sengar, Fear's journey from a respected Weapons Master to a figure ensnared in divine machinations and familial turmoil provides a compelling narrative that mirrors the broader themes of destiny, loyalty, and the tragic consequences of power.

Fear Sengar from Malazan Book of the Fallen
Fear Sengar, Weapons Master

Fear Sengar: The Edur's Reluctant Hero

Fear Sengar, described as a tall, broad-shouldered Tiste Edur with a well-muscled body and dark eyes, carries the weight of his people's expectations and the responsibilities of his lineage with a stoic determination. His prowess in battle and deep sense of duty to his tribe and family define his path, setting the stage for a journey fraught with challenges that test his will, his heart, and his very soul.

The Path to Power: Midnight Tides and Beyond

In Midnight Tides, Fear's loyalty to the Tiste Edur and his initial support of Hannan Mosag's vision for unification mark him as a staunch defender of his people's traditions and glory. However, the devastating summoning against the Letherii poachers and the subsequent quest that leads to Rhulad's resurrection and transformation into an emperor propelled by the Crippled God unveil the first cracks in Fear's unwavering loyalty. His inner conflict, caught between allegiance to his brother and the harrowing realization of the corrupted forces at play, sets the tone for his ensuing struggle.

Betrayal and Heartbreak

As Rhulad spirals into tyranny, Fear's world unravels, stripped of his betrothed, Mayen, and witnessing the horrifying metamorphosis of his beloved brother into a puppet of malevolent gods. His participation in the conquest of Lether and the internal strife within the Edur epitomize the toll of Rhulad's reign, highlighting Fear's growing disillusionment with the path his people have taken.

A Quest for Redemption: Reaper's Gale and The Journey's End

Fear's determination to restore Kurald Emurlahn and his alliance with Silchas Ruin and Seren Pedac in Reaper's Gale reveal a man desperate to reclaim his people's honor and rectify the wrongs that have led to so much suffering. His arduous journey, fraught with danger and betrayal, underscores his resilience and commitment to a cause greater than himself, even as his leadership is challenged and his choices lead to dire consequences.

A Hero's Tragic Fall

The culmination of Fear's quest in a confrontation that ends in his death is a poignant reminder of the relentless cycle of betrayal and vengeance that haunts the Tiste Edur. His final act, an attempt to strike down Silchas Ruin to prevent further bloodshed among his people, albeit misguided, is a testament to his enduring love for his brother Trull and his unwavering desire to protect the Edur from further devastation.

Legacy of Fear Sengar: A Reflection on Power and Sacrifice

Fear Sengar's narrative arc, from a revered warrior to a tragic figure consumed by a quest for redemption, embodies the essence of the Malazan series' exploration of power, loyalty, and the cost of ambition. His story is a cautionary tale of the perils inherent in unchecked authority and the corrosive effects of divine manipulation on mortal realms.

In the end, Fear Sengar's legacy is one of profound complexity, marked by his strengths and vulnerabilities. His journey reflects the turmoil of a soul caught in the maelstrom of history and destiny, striving to forge a path of honor in a world where such ideals are often overshadowed by darker forces. Fear's life and death serve as a mirror to the struggles faced by all who seek to navigate the treacherous waters of power, identity, and allegiance in the Malazan universe.

Fear Sengar's Raw Power

Fear's preeminence among the Hiroth warriors, noted for having more trophies on his belt than any of his brothers, is a testament to his combat capabilities and his significant role in the Edur's unification wars. His physical description as tall, broad-shouldered, and well-muscled underlines his physicality and readiness for combat. These attributes, combined with his leadership in battle, contribute significantly to his raw power in a direct combat scenario.

However, when evaluating Fear's raw power against the vast backdrop of fantasy characters from various universes, it's essential to consider the diversity and scope of powers that exist within the genre. Characters in other worlds might wield vast elemental powers, command magical forces that can alter reality, or possess divine attributes that far exceed human capabilities.

Given this context, maintaining Fear's rating at a 6 in "raw power" remains appropriate and fair. This rating acknowledges his superior combat skills, physical strength, and tactical prowess within the confines of human (or human-like) capabilities but also recognizes the limitations when compared to characters who operate with a broader spectrum of supernatural abilities. Fear's raw power is formidable within his own universe, especially against similarly skilled or powered opponents, but in a cross-universe comparison, the rating reflects a balanced view of his capabilities relative to the extraordinary powers exhibited by characters in other fantasy settings.

Fear Sengar's Tactical Ability

Fear's tactical acumen is displayed through several key narrative arcs. Notably, his initial engagement with the Letherii poachers and the subsequent decision to oppose Hannan Mosag's reliance on summoned forces rather than traditional martial prowess underline a critical strategic insight. He recognizes the importance of preserving the Edur's martial traditions and the potential consequences of deviating from these practices.

Moreover, the quest to retrieve the sword from the ice fields, despite being based on a vision of the Warlock King, showcases Fear's ability to lead under uncertain and perilous conditions. The challenges faced and the tragic outcome of this quest highlight his capacity to make difficult decisions in the face of unforeseen consequences, a crucial aspect of tactical ability.

However, Fear's strategic decisions are also marked by the constraints of loyalty and tradition, occasionally hindering his ability to adapt to changing circumstances. His allegiance to Rhulad, despite the latter's descent into tyranny, reflects a conflict between duty and strategic pragmatism, impacting his overall effectiveness as a tactician.

Considering Fear's strategic and tactical capabilities in the broader spectrum of fantasy characters, the rating of 5 is justified. This rating acknowledges his demonstrated competence in military leadership and strategic planning while recognizing the limitations imposed by his adherence to tradition and loyalty. It positions Fear as average in tactical ability when compared to all fantasy characters, respecting his skills and achievements within the Malazan universe but also noting the extraordinary tactical genius and adaptability seen in broader fantasy literature.

Fear Sengar's Influence

Fear's influence is most evident in his interactions with his brothers and his ability to mobilize and lead the Tiste Edur armies. Despite the complexities of their relationships, especially with Trull and Rhulad, Fear's decisions and actions significantly impact the narrative's direction and the fates of those around him. His loyalty to his family and his tribe, even in the face of Rhulad's tyrannical descent, underscores a complex form of influence rooted in duty and tradition rather than manipulation or charisma.

However, Fear's influence is not without its limitations. His adherence to tradition and his struggle to navigate the changing political and spiritual landscape of the Tiste Edur often hinder his ability to effect broader change or to sway others outside his immediate circle. The tragic elements of his journey, including his responses to Rhulad's rise to power and the loss of Mayen, reflect a character whose influence is deeply personal and, at times, constrained by the very traditions and loyalties that define him.

Considering the scope of fantasy universes, where characters can wield immense magical powers or command vast legions through sheer will, Fear's influence, characterized by leadership within traditional societal structures and familial loyalty, warrants a reassessment. A revised rating of 5.5 acknowledges his significant, though somewhat circumscribed, ability to lead and influence within the Malazan narrative. This rating situates Fear as above average in influence among fantasy characters, recognizing his role as a leader and a warrior within his society while also accounting for the broader spectrum of influence displayed across various fantasy realms.

Fear Sengar's Resilience

Physically, Fear is a formidable warrior, honed through years of training and battle. His encounters on the ice fields and the subsequent trials he endures underscore a robust physical resilience. However, it is his mental and emotional resilience that truly defines his character. Fear navigates the treacherous political landscape of the Tiste Edur, endures the loss of his betrothed to his brother Rhulad, and grapples with the moral quandaries posed by Rhulad's tyrannical rule. Despite these adversities, Fear remains steadfast in his duties, continually seeking ways to protect and guide his people toward a better future.

Moreover, Fear's journey with Silchas Ruin and his quest for redemption highlight his resilience in facing the unknown and the potentially unachievable. His determination to rectify the fractures within his world, even in the face of daunting odds, showcases an enduring spirit that refuses to be quelled by despair or defeat.

Given the breadth of characters across all fantasy universes, some of whom possess supernatural abilities to recover from injury or manipulate reality to avoid harm, a rating of 7 in resilience for Fear Sengar is both tough and fair. This rating acknowledges the multifaceted nature of his resilience—spanning the physical, mental, and emotional realms—while also recognizing the extraordinary levels of resilience exhibited by characters with magical or divine powers in the broader fantasy genre.

Fear Sengar's Versatility

As a warrior, Fear demonstrates considerable skill and adaptability, wielding traditional weapons with expertise and engaging in battles that require both physical strength and strategic thinking. However, his versatility extends beyond the battlefield. Fear's journey into the northern ice fields, his interactions with the Crippled God's influence on Rhulad, and his subsequent quest to find Scabandari Bloodeye's imprisoned spirit all illustrate his capacity to confront and adapt to a wide range of situations. These tasks demand not only martial ability but also diplomatic tact, emotional resilience, and spiritual insight.

Despite his strengths, Fear's versatility is sometimes constrained by his loyalties and the weight of tradition. His dedication to his family and the Tiste Edur way of life, while admirable, occasionally limits his ability to fully explore alternative paths or solutions to the challenges he faces. This tension between duty and the potential for broader adaptability is a recurring theme in his character arc.

Given the expansive nature of fantasy universes, where characters may wield vast magical powers, shape-shift, or traverse different realms at will, a nuanced assessment of Fear's versatility is warranted. maintaining his rating as 5 acknowledges his adaptability across the physical, emotional, and spiritual domains he navigates. This rating reflects a recognition of Fear's ability to engage with a diverse array of challenges, even as it acknowledges the inherent limitations imposed by his circumstances and personal loyalties.

Fear Sengar's Alignment

Fear's commitment to the Tiste Edur's laws and customs is evident throughout the series. He respects the hierarchical structures of his society, fulfilling his duties with a sense of responsibility that is indicative of a Lawful alignment. This respect for order and tradition guides his actions, from leading his people in battle to navigating the complex politics that arise from Rhulad's ascension and the machinations of the Crippled God. His decision to support Rhulad initially, despite personal reservations, further demonstrates his allegiance to the societal laws and expectations of the Tiste Edur.

However, Fear's alignment also leans towards "Neutral" in his moral and ethical considerations. He is driven by a sense of duty and loyalty to his family and people, yet he is also capable of questioning the righteousness of their actions and the consequences of their adherence to power. His journey reflects a struggle between his obligations and his personal moral compass, illustrating a character caught between the rigidity of law and the complexities of ethical nuance. This duality is particularly evident in his reactions to Rhulad’s increasingly tyrannical rule and his own internal conflict regarding the path his brother has taken.

Taking into account Fear Sengar's strict adherence to the laws and traditions of his people, combined with his nuanced moral stance that does not strictly adhere to a dichotomy of good or evil, his alignment can be defined as "Lawful Neutral." This alignment accurately reflects Fear’s position as a character who operates within the confines of his society’s laws, yet does so with a personal code that acknowledges the grey areas of morality and ethics. He respects authority and tradition but is also guided by a sense of pragmatism and introspection that allows him to navigate the complex moral landscape of his world. Pride and Prophecy keeps an updated character alignment matrix across all planes of existence.

Fear's Trophy Case

PPET Rankings

Season Rank
1 (2023-2024) #80 (of 107)

Overall Conclusion on Fear Sengar and Position Across Planes of Existence

Fear Sengar's standing at a 5.7 in the context of power levels across all fantasy universes is a testament to his complex and multifaceted character within Steven Erikson's Malazan Book of the Fallen. This rating, which situates him as above average, reflects a synthesis of his raw power, tactical ability, influence, resilience, and versatility. It acknowledges the strengths and limitations inherent in his character and compares them to the vast array of characters in fantasy literature, where power can manifest in myriad forms, from the wielding of vast magical abilities to the subtler strengths of leadership and moral integrity.

Fear's raw power, primarily rooted in his exceptional skills as a warrior and his physical prowess, is significant within his own universe. However, when placed in the broader context of fantasy characters, who may command elements, alter realities, or possess divine strength, his physical and martial abilities represent a more grounded form of power. His tactical ability, marked by his leadership during the Edur's conflicts and his strategic insights, showcases his intellect and capacity for planning. Yet, in worlds where strategy can involve manipulating the fabric of magic itself, Fear's tactical prowess is a reflection of his human limitations and the challenges he faces within his societal and cultural constraints.

Fear's influence, primarily derived from his status within Tiste Edur society and his moral leadership, highlights his ability to impact those around him significantly. His resilience, particularly in the face of personal and societal upheaval, further underscores his strength of character. These attributes, while impressive, are considered in the context of characters who may reshape societies with words, or recover from mortal wounds through magic, placing Fear's influence and resilience in a broader perspective.

Fear's versatility, demonstrated through his adaptability in combat, diplomacy, and the pursuit of his objectives, speaks to a character capable of navigating diverse challenges. However, in the grand tapestry of fantasy universes, where versatility can include mastery of multiple magic systems, shape-shifting, or interdimensional travel, Fear's abilities reflect a more nuanced, albeit narrower, spectrum of adaptability.

Considering the diverse ways in which power is defined and manifested across fantasy literature, Fear Sengar's rating of 5.7 captures his above-average status among fantasy characters. It recognizes the depth and complexity of his abilities, while also acknowledging the extraordinary scope of powers present in the genre. Fear's journey, marked by personal growth, strategic acumen, and the constant negotiation of his moral and ethical boundaries, exemplifies the power of human resilience, intelligence, and integrity in the face of daunting challenges.

This rating not only honors Fear Sengar's achievements and strengths but also places them within the context of the broader fantasy genre, acknowledging the richness and diversity of characters that populate these imaginative universes. Fear stands as a compelling figure whose power, while not the most spectacular in the realm of fantasy, is significant for its depth, realism, and the profound impact it has within the Malazan series. Pride and Prophecy keeps an updated power ranking across all planes of existence. This will only be sortable on desktop viewing. The below table shows a summary within the same plane of existence of this article.