Arena Season 2 is Live (Live Results on X and Bluesky)

Black Company Character Analysis: The Faceless Man

Race: Human

Transcendent: Taken

Sex: Male

Faction: The Empire

Overall Rating: 5.9

Alignment: Neutral Evil

Arena Status: Active (S1)

The Faceless Man, a shadowy figure from Glen Cook's "The Black Company" series, stands as a testament to the enigmatic and often murky world of the series' dark fantasy. As one of the original Ten Who Were Taken, his presence looms large over the narrative, despite the scarcity of direct encounters or detailed descriptions of him within the Annals, primarily chronicled by Croaker, the company's Annalist. This character's elusive nature only amplifies the intrigue and speculation surrounding him, making him a focal point for fans and theorists alike.

The Faceless Man from The Black Company
The Faceless Man, One of The Ten Who Were Taken

Introduction to The Faceless Man

The Faceless Man, also known as the Nameless, is woven into the fabric of the Black Company's lore, his actions and the mystery of his identity contributing to the dark, foreboding atmosphere that characterizes the series. His participation in significant events like the reconquest of the city of Barns and the pivotal Battle of Charm underscores his importance within the Lady's Empire and the broader conflict against the Rebel forces.

The Enigma of the Faceless Man

One of the most compelling aspects of the Faceless Man is the lack of personal detail about him, a trait that he shares with his fellow Taken. Annals, the primary source of history in the series, provide scant personal information on the Faceless Man, focusing instead on his deeds. This narrative choice by Glen Cook adds layers of mystery and invites speculation, making the Faceless Man a subject of fascination.

Key Appearances and Major Plot Points

The Black Company: The Faceless Man's military prowess is highlighted through his leadership in the campaign across the Plain of Fear and the defense of the Tower at Charm. His supposed death, alongside Moonbiter, marks a significant moment in the series, hinting at the lethal intrigues among the Taken.

Bleak Seasons: The potential survival of the Faceless Man, suggested through Murgen's visions, introduces a tantalizing possibility that not all is as it seems. The expedition by Otto and Hagop to unearth his true fate adds a layer of detective work to the narrative, enriching the lore with their findings—or lack thereof.

The Mystery of Identity

The speculation around the Faceless Man's true identity and fate speaks volumes about the series' engagement with themes of uncertainty and the unknown. The idea that Longshadow might be the Faceless Man, though ultimately disproven, serves as a narrative device to explore the depths of the past and the implications of the Taken's supposed deaths.

Legacy and Impact

The Faceless Man's legacy is one of ambiguity, power, and intrigue. His actions, as much as his absence, shape the events of the series, leaving a lasting impact on the characters and the world they inhabit. The speculation surrounding his identity and fate exemplifies the series' ability to weave complex narratives that engage readers in a deep, ongoing process of discovery.

The Faceless Man's enigmatic presence in "The Black Company" series serves as a compelling focal point for discussions about identity, loyalty, and the nature of power. Despite—or perhaps because of—the limited information available about him, he remains one of the series' most intriguing characters, embodying the dark, uncertain world that Glen Cook masterfully creates. Through the Faceless Man, Cook explores the themes of unknown histories and the shadows that past deeds cast on the present, making him an unforgettable part of this dark fantasy saga.

The Faceless Man's Raw Power

The Faceless Man's prowess, as hinted at through the collective actions of the Ten and the sparse mentions of his individual accomplishments, suggests a being of formidable magical and physical capabilities. Leading an army across the Plain of Fear to reclaim the city of Barns underscores not only his command over formidable sorcerous abilities but also his strategic acumen in martial endeavors. Furthermore, his significant role in the defense of the Tower during the Battle of Charm—against formidable Rebel forces—underscores a masterful application of raw power in a pivotal combat scenario. However, the exact nature of his magic, whether it leans more towards destructive spells, manipulation of the elements, or other arcane crafts, remains largely speculative.

Given the broad spectrum of fantasy characters, who range from beings capable of altering the fabric of reality to those whose might is limited to physical prowess or localized magical feats, placing The Faceless Man on this scale is challenging. The rating of 6 previously assigned suggests he is perceived as possessing considerable power, albeit not at the pinnacle of what is depicted in fantasy literature.

However, considering his contributions to the Lady's Empire and his status among the Ten Who Were Taken—beings feared and respected across the series' universe—there's an argument to be made for a slight upward adjustment. His capabilities in both leading an army and directly engaging in significant battles suggest a level of power that is not easily matched.

In light of this, a revised rating of 6.5 might better reflect The Faceless Man's raw power within the context of all fantasy universes. This acknowledges his demonstrated might and influence while also recognizing the limitations in our understanding of his full potential due to the narrative's focus. Such a rating situates him as an above-average entity in the realm of fantasy characters, capable of feats that command respect and fear, yet still shrouded in enough mystery to preclude a higher score without further evidence of his capabilities.

The Faceless Man's Tactical Ability

The Faceless Man exhibits a tactical acumen that's both formidable and enigmatic. His actions during the reconquest of Barns and the pivotal Battle of Charm highlight a strategic mind capable of orchestrating complex military operations against formidable foes. The Faceless Man's ability to lead an army across the treacherous Plain of Fear to successfully reclaim the city of Barns for the Lady's Empire is a testament to his adeptness in maneuvering forces in hostile territories. This feat alone demonstrates not only raw power but also a nuanced understanding of terrain, enemy psychology, and the art of war.

Further exemplifying his tactical prowess, the Faceless Man played a crucial role in the defense of the Tower during the Battle of Charm. This battle, a defining moment for the Lady's Empire, saw him marshaling forces against the numerically superior Rebel armies commanded by the Circle of Eighteen. His participation in this defense underscores a capacity for both planning and execution under pressure, qualities essential to a high tactical rating.

However, the details surrounding the Faceless Man are scarce, and much of his tactical ability is inferred from group actions rather than individual feats. His presumed death in a duel with Moonbiter, "consumed by the feud among the Taken," adds a layer of complexity to assessing his standalone tactical ability. This incident suggests a propensity for personal vendettas that could cloud judgment, potentially detracting from his effectiveness as a strategist in a broader context.

The rating of 6 out of 10 acknowledges his demonstrated strategic competence and contributions to the Lady's Empire while accounting for the limitations in available information and the potential impact of personal vendettas on his tactical decision-making. The rating reflects his successful military campaigns and strategic value to the Lady's Empire, tempered by the nuances of his character and the broader context of tactical ability across fantasy literature.

The Faceless Man's Influence

Unlike characters who wield influence through overt leadership, diplomacy, or personal charisma, The Faceless Man's influence is more enigmatic and indirect. His role within the Lady's Empire and his participation in key battles demonstrate a capacity to shape events from behind the scenes. However, this form of influence is less about persuasion or leadership in the traditional sense and more about the imposition of will through force and the strategic manipulation of circumstances.

Given the scarcity of direct information about The Faceless Man, particularly from Croaker's Annals, his influence is largely inferred from his actions and the reputation of the Ten Who Were Taken as a whole. His ability to lead armies and contribute significantly to the Lady's war efforts speaks to a form of influence that is deeply intertwined with the machinations of power in the series. Yet, this influence is somewhat spectral, emanating from the fear and respect his capabilities and mystique command rather than from any personal relationships or alliances he might forge.

In comparison to all fantasy characters across all universes, rating The Faceless Man's influence is a challenging task. His influence, while significant within the context of his own universe, might not translate as directly when placed against characters who lead nations, wield magical powers to sway the hearts and minds of thousands, or whose decisions can alter the fabric of reality itself. Considering this, a rating of 5 out of 10 seems appropriate. This reflects his notable but limited influence within a highly competitive field of characters, many of whom have more explicit forms of influence and broader scopes of impact.

The Faceless Man's Resilience

In assessing The Faceless Man's resilience, we must consider the broader context of his existence within a world fraught with betrayal, magic, and war. The very nature of his survival, despite the alleged mutual kill with Moonbiter and the lack of a body to confirm his death, speaks to an inherent resilience. This resilience is not just physical but also situational, indicating a deep-seated survival instinct and possibly the use of magical means or cunning to navigate the perils of his world.

The ambiguity surrounding his death and the speculation of his survival suggest a character whose resilience is built on adaptability and possibly an ability to evade death itself, a trait that is both fascinating and hard to quantify. Within the scope of all fantasy universes, characters demonstrate resilience in varied ways, from healing powers to enduring loyalty to a cause, making The Faceless Man's form of resilience—survival through obscurity and the fostering of legends—unique yet difficult to compare.

Given these considerations, maintaining a resilience rating of 6 seems appropriate. This rating acknowledges his demonstrated ability to survive, if not physically, then in the memories and fears of others, without placing him on par with characters who show more overt and quantifiable forms of resilience, such as regenerative abilities or unyielding resistance to magical attacks. The justification for this rating lies in the blend of myth and reality that defines his character, allowing him to persist in the series' lore in ways that defy traditional understanding of resilience.

The Faceless Man's Versatility

The Faceless Man, akin to his fellow Taken, is presumed to possess a broad spectrum of magical abilities, a hallmark of his versatility. His involvement in significant battles, such as the reconquest of the city of Barns and the pivotal Battle of Charm, underlines a proficiency in both large-scale magical warfare and the subtleties of magical espionage and manipulation. This dual capability suggests a character who can adapt his magical prowess to varying circumstances, a trait that is exceedingly valuable in the universe of the Black Company, where the line between friend and foe is often blurred.

The Faceless Man's role in leading armies and defending crucial strongholds against formidable enemies indicates not just raw power but a strategic mind capable of adapting to the changing tides of battle. His participation in the defense of the Tower during the Battle of Charm showcases an ability to employ both direct confrontation and perhaps more nuanced, strategic uses of power to achieve his ends.

The very lack of detailed information on The Faceless Man's abilities might itself be considered a form of versatility. In a universe where knowledge equals power, his obscured history and capabilities could serve as a strategic advantage, allowing him to surprise opponents and allies alike with unforeseen tactics and powers.

While primarily a background character, The Faceless Man's influence and the speculative breadth of his abilities suggest a character who could, under different circumstances, play a multitude of roles within the series. From a direct antagonist to a shadowy benefactor, his versatility in potential narrative functions mirrors his presumed versatility in skills and magical abilities.

Given the broad scope of fantasy characters across various universes, rating The Faceless Man’s versatility poses a challenge. However, considering the aforementioned aspects, a fair assessment would place him at a 6 out of 10. This rating acknowledges his demonstrated strategic flexibility and the potential diversity of his magical abilities. The rating is justified by considering his potential impact on the narrative and strategic engagements, despite the scarcity of direct encounters or detailed descriptions of his powers. His ability to adapt and the strategic advantage his mysterious nature provides set him apart as a character with significant, albeit largely implicit, versatility.

The Faceless Man's Alignment

The Faceless Man's actions and the limited insights into his motivations suggest a character driven by self-interest and the pursuit of power, typical traits of a Neutral Evil alignment. This alignment is characterized by a lack of commitment to either lawfulness or chaos, allowing individuals to operate within or outside societal norms as long as it serves their objectives. The Faceless Man's involvement in significant battles for the Lady's Empire, his strategic manipulation of forces, and his readiness to engage in conflict for personal or aligned gain without regard for broader ethical considerations exemplify this alignment.

His role in the reconquest of Barns and defense during the Battle of Charm, while serving the Lady's interests, also highlights a willingness to use any means necessary to achieve his ends, further aligning with Neutral Evil traits. The ambiguous nature of his demise, consumed by internal feuds among the Taken, underscores the treacherous dynamics that often accompany such alignments, where alliances and actions are purely opportunistic.

The Faceless Man, through his actions, strategic engagements, and the overarching pursuit of power, embodies the essence of Neutral Evil. His alignment reflects a character who prioritizes self-interest and power, unbound by the dichotomies of law and chaos, willing to navigate the complexities of the Black Company's universe in ways that serve his ends. This determination of "Neutral Evil" aligns with his portrayed actions and the inherent moral ambiguity that defines much of the series' exploration of power, loyalty, and survival. Pride and Prophecy keeps an updated character alignment matrix across all planes of existence.

The Faceless Man's Trophy Case

PPET Rankings

Season Rank
1 (2023-2024) #78 (of 107)

Overall Conclusion on The Faceless Man and Position Across Planes of Existence

The Faceless Man from Glen Cook's "The Black Company" series embodies a compelling enigma within the fantasy genre. His rating of 5.9 across all fantasy universes positions him as slightly above average in terms of power, a distinction that requires a nuanced understanding of his role and capabilities within his own universe, compared to the broader spectrum of fantasy characters.

The Faceless Man's rating is grounded in several key aspects of his character and the context within which he operates. First, his status as one of the Ten Who Were Taken signifies a considerable level of power, particularly in magical abilities and martial prowess. His contributions to the Lady's Empire, notably his strategic leadership in the reconquest of Barns and a significant role in the defense during the Battle of Charm, showcase not only raw power but also tactical acumen. However, the scarcity of detailed information about his personal feats, compared to other prominent figures in fantasy literature, necessitates a cautious approach to rating his power level.

In the vast expanse of fantasy universes, characters wield power that ranges from world-altering magic to godlike abilities. The Faceless Man's power, while formidable within the context of "The Black Company," may not reach the heights of characters who can, for instance, alter the fabric of reality or command armies of the undead with a mere thought. This relative measure accounts for the 5.9 rating, situating him above the median but acknowledging the existence of more overwhelmingly powerful entities in other narratives.

The Faceless Man's alignment as Neutral Evil further informs his position. His motivations, shrouded in mystery and self-interest, add a layer of unpredictability to his power. Unlike characters driven by noble causes or destructive chaos, his actions are guided by personal gain and strategic advantage, making him a dangerous adversary but also limiting his potential for alliances and broader influence.

Moreover, the very essence of his character—a faceless, somewhat nebulous figure—suggests a versatility and adaptability that is a form of power in itself. Yet, the lack of concrete achievements that surpass the extraordinary feats of other fantasy characters constrains his rating.

The Faceless Man's rating as slightly above average in the grand scheme of fantasy universes is a reflection of his complex role within "The Black Company." His enigmatic nature, combined with demonstrated tactical and magical abilities, positions him as a formidable figure. However, when juxtaposed with the broader fantasy genre's array of characters, his power, while significant, does not reach the upper echelons of omnipotence or world-altering influence.

This nuanced evaluation recognizes the inherent limitations of comparing characters across vastly different worlds and narratives, emphasizing the importance of context in assessing power levels. Pride and Prophecy keeps an updated power ranking across all planes of existence. This will only be sortable on desktop viewing. The below table shows a summary within the same plane of existence of this article.